“Meaty” Children’s Songs?
Kay has recently opened up a discussion on twitter about the sort of songs children’s leaders choose to use in kids work.
As an introduction to what we are saying, we should tell you that Steve writes excellent songs, full of teaching/information that are usable with both church and non church kids (Mainly for 5 – 7 year olds and all age worship, but some for older kids too).
He recently received his royalty update and found that for use in church, his best selling song was one he wrote as what he calls a “throw away fun song” – no teaching, no theology – just a list of actions, with the only religious words being “…as we praise the Lord”.
We believe kids are capable of so much more, and the songs we choose for them to learn and sing should reflect this – many children love some of the adult praise songs and understand what they mean, so why not use good, solid teaching songs written for the age and stage of the children we work with?
Over the years we have heard other song writers say the same thing, as some kids albums seem to be happy to settle for songs that fit into the “I can shake this or that to make God smile” culture.
We understand the issues kids workers want to avoid, namely, making non Christian kids sing words they don’t believe – but is there an argument to be made that God understands this? He’s not going to strike them with lightening because they don’t believe the songs they are singing – after all, many adults do it every Sunday in our churches!
In a world where many adult Christians learn most of their theology from songs – it is true to say that many kids and teens do the same.
On a similar theme – how similar or different should our music with kids be? Should we be emulating music that often comes from an angst ridden gang culture, or should we be different?
Some good writers to look out for (Apart from Steve!): Trevor Ranger – new album out and brilliant! Dave Godfrey, Doug Horley and of course, the lovely Ishmael!